In Haskell, how can you sort a list of infinite lists of strings?
haskell, infinite, list, sorting, string
Solution
Ultimately, you can't sort an infinite list, because items at the tail of the list could percolate all the way to the front of the result, so you can't finish sorting an infinite list until you've seen the last item, but your list is infinite, so you'll never get there.
The only way that you could even try to sort an infinite list would require constraints on the inhabitants of the list. If the values of the list items comes from a well-founded set and the contents of the list are unique then you could at least make some progress in returning elements the initial elements of the list. For instance if the list was of distinct natural numbers, you could return the first 0 you see, then the first 1, etc. but you couldn't make any headway in the result until you saw 2, no matter how far down the list you went. Ultimately, if you ever skipped an element in the set because it wasn't present in the source, you'd cease to produce new output elements until you had the entire input in hand.
You can do the same thing with strings, because they are well founded, but that is only even remotely viable if you plan on returning all possible strings.
In short, if you need this, you're going about solving the problem you have in the wrong way. This isn't a tractable path to any solution you will want to use.
As yairchu noted, merging a finite number of sorted infinite lists works fine though.
Problem
So basically, if I have a (finite or infinite) list of (finite or infinite) lists of strings, is it possible to sort the list by length first and then by lexicographic order, excluding duplicates? A sample input/output would be: Input: [["a", "b",...], ["a", "aa", "aaa"], ["b", "bb", "bbb",...], ...] Output: ["a", "b", "aa", "bb", "aaa", "bbb", ...] I know that the input list is not a valid haskell expression but suppose that there is an input like that. I tried using merge algorithm but it tends to hang on the inputs that I give it. Can somebody explain and show a decent sorting function that can do this? If there isn't any function like that, can you explain why? In case somebody didn't understand what I meant by the sorting order, I meant that shortest length strings are sorted first AND if one or more strings are of same length then they are sorted using < operator. Thanks!