Integer handled as reference type when passed into a delegate

c#, delegates

Solution

I argumentend, because int is a value type, the actual value that is passed into Console.WriteLine() gets copied

That is exactly correct. When you call `WriteLine` the value will be copied.

So, when are you calling `WriteLine`? It's not in the `for` loop. You're not writing anything at that point in time, you're just creating a delegate.

It's not until the `foreach` loop when you invoke the delegate, it's at that time that the value in the variable `i` is copied to the stack for the call to `WriteLine`.

So, what's the value of `i` during the `foreach` loop? It's 10, for each iteration of the `foreach` loop.

So now you're asking, "well how is `i` anything during the `foreach loop, isn't it out of scope`. Well, no, it's not. What this is demonstrating is a "closure". When an anonymous method reference a variable that variable's scope needs to last for as long as that anonymous method, which could be for any period of time. If nothing special is done at all reading the variable would be random garbage containing whatever happened to be stuck in that location in memory. C# actively makes sure that situation can't happen.

So what does it do? It creates a closure class; it's a class that will contain a number of fields representing everything that is closed over. In other words, the code will be refactored to look something like this:

public class ClosureClass
{
    public int i;

    public void DoStuff()
    {
        Console.WriteLine(i);
    }
}

class Program
{
    delegate void Writer();

    static void Main(string[] args)
    {
        var writers = new List<Writer>();
        ClosureClass closure = new ClosureClass();
        for (closure.i = 0; closure.i < 10; closure.i++)
        {
            writers.Add(closure.DoStuff);
        }

        foreach (Writer writer in writers)
        {
            writer();
        }
    }
}

Now we both have a name for our anonymous method (all anonymous methods are given a name by the compiler) and we can ensure that the variable will live for as long as the delegate that refers to the anonymous function lives.

Looking at this refactor, I hope it's clear why the result is that `10` is printed 10 times.

Problem

I was attending the TechDays 2013 in the Netherlands this week and I got an interesting quiz question presented. The question was: What is the output of the following program. Here is what the code looks like. ``` class Program { delegate void Writer(); static void Main(string[] args) { var writers = new List<Writer>(); for (int i = 0; i < 10; i++) { writers.Add(delegate { Console.WriteLine(i); }); } foreach (Writer writer in writers) { writer(); } } } ``` Obviously, the answer I gave was wrong. I argumentend, because int is a value type, the actual value that is passed into `Console.WriteLine()` gets copied, so the output would be 0...9. However `i` is handled as a reference type in this situation. The correct answer is that it will display ten times 10. Can anyone explain why and how?

Original source

Related problems