Is it bad form to let C# garbage collect a list instead of reusing it?
c#, garbage-collection, list
Solution
It depends a bit on how many elements are in the list. If the array backing the list is large enough to be on the large object heap, then you might be better off clearing the list and reusing it. This will reduce the number of large memory allocations, and will help reduce the problem of large object heap fragmentation. (See http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/magazine/cc534993.aspx and http://www.simple-talk.com/dotnet/.net-framework/the-dangers-of-the-large-object-heap/ for more information; see http://blogs.msdn.com/b/dotnet/archive/2011/10/04/large-object-heap-improvements-in-net-4-5.aspx for improvements due with .NET 4.5)
If the lists are small, you might be better off just creating a new list, or you might get better performance calling `Clear()`. When in doubt, measure the performance.
Edit: In response to the philosophical question you pose in your edit, here are two reasons to create a new list:
- In general, code is cleaner and easier to reason about if you do not reuse objects. The cost of garbage collection is low, the cost of confusing code is high.
- Consider what happens if the code dumping the list's contents is in another function, as it most likely is. Once you've passed that list out of its local context, it's possible that there are non-local references to the same list. Other code might be modifying the list, or might be assuming (incorrectly) that you're not modifying it.
Problem
I have a list of elements that steadily grows, until I dump all the data from that list into a file. I then want to reuse that list for the same purpose again. Is it bad practice to simply assign it to a new list, instead of removing all the elements from the list? It seems garbage collection should take care of the old list, and that way I don't have to worry about removing the elements. For example: ``` var myList = new List<element>(); myList.Add(someElement); myList.Add(anotherElement); // dumps the elements into a file myList = new List<element>(); ``` Edit: Even if there are easy ways around this, I was wondering too about the philosophical side of it. Is it bad to let something be garbage collected if there is a way around it? What are the costs of allowing garbage collection vs deleting the elements and reusing the same memory?